Textbook Evaluation Process

Before deciding to shift to a new textbook, evaluating your current textbook thoroughly is essential. In addition to using the textbook evaluation rubric, consider the following to guide your evaluation process:

  1. Textbook components that require review: 
  • Identify the key elements you want to assess (e.g., pedagogical approach, cultural content, user-friendliness, or technological features): Which areas are most relevant to your course objectives and student needs?
  1. Stakeholder involvement: Consider involving a variety of stakeholders, such as:
  • Instructors, who can offer valuable insight into the textbook’s strengths and challenges
  • Students, whose feedback on the textbook’s clarity, usability, and engagement is crucial
  • Administrators, who can provide input on budget constraints, resource availability, and institutional needs
  1. Learning preferences, usability, and engagement: Use surveys, focus groups, or classroom observations consider:
  • How well the textbook meets students' learning preferences and content interests
  • If students can comprehend the material easily or if there are obstacles
  • To what degree the textbook engages and motivates students across different proficiency levels

Once feedback has been collected, analyze it and determine whether minor adjustments can be made to the current textbook (e.g., supplementing with additional resources) or whether a complete textbook change is necessary if the feedback reveals significant shortcomings. This process should be iterative, with regular re-evaluation to ensure the textbook aligns with evolving educational goals and student needs. This approach will help ensure that any shift to a new textbook is thoughtful and informed by comprehensive feedback.

< Previous Next >